PIE & COFFEE Evanston
749 Chicago Avenue, Evanston IL

Today's Start-of-day Pie Menu (come early for best selection)

Sunday September 27th, 2020

The BLT is Back!!!
Now open until 8pm on Thursday, Friday, Saturday.
See a complete listing of hours below the menu

Sweet Pies

  • Apple
  • Chocolate Peanut Butter Crunch Chess
  • Chocolate Cream
  • Cookies and Cream
  • Lemon Meringue
  • Sour Cream Dutch Pear
  • Plum Gooseberry with Pecan Crumble
  • Peach
  • Cherry Limeade
Savory Pies
  • Chicken Pot Pie
  • Roasted Vegetable Feta
  • Pork Apple Sage
  • Curry Lamb
  • Chicken Tomatillo
Hand Pie
  • Chorizo Black Bean
  • Spinach Ricotta Feta
  • Mushroom 
  • Moroccan Lamb 
Soup of the Day
  • Zucchini Corn Cheddar 
  • Bacon Potato Garlic Chive Cheddar
  • Ham Roasted Peppers Leeks Gruyere
  • Arugula Roasted Tomato Corn Gruyere
  • Broccoli. Ricotta Parmesan Sage

House Made Ice Cream

  • Vanilla

Pie Shop Notes

Meet me at the corner of Pie & Coffee
Also known in Evanston as the corner of Chicago & Kedzie. We are one block south of the Main Street Stations of both the CTA Purple line and the Metra Union Pacific North Line.

Current Hours:
Tuesday CLOSED
Wednesday 8 am-3 pm
Thursday 8 am-8 pm
Friday 8 am-8 pm
Saturday 8 am-8 pm
Sunday 9 am-3 pm

Ring Us

About parking
Free Indoor Parking right behind the shop.  Entrance to parking on Chicago Avenue ½ block south of the shop.

View Hoosier Mama Evanston in a larger map


©2013 Hoosier Mama Pie Company ~ Designed by DesignScout