Follow HMPC on Twitter



Evanston Location

Evanston Online                        Why we don't ship...


Now taking orders for the Pi Day (Mar 13th & 14th)

To place an order for these days click PI DAY!



As we make all our pies from scratch we do require orders to be placed by 9pm 2 days prior to pickup. For example if you would like to pickup a pie anytime on Friday, the order needs to be placed by 9pm on Wednesday. Sometimes - often during the holidays - we may have to stop accepting orders once we reach our capacity. We hate to do this, but it is necessary to maintain the quality of our pies.


Customer Information
Pickup Information
Order Information
APPLE HONEY CURRANT - $32.00
Double crust pie with apples, buckwheat honey, and dried currants.
APPLE PIE - $30.00
Classic two crust apple pie. Not too sweet with more fruit than goo in a delicious buttery crust. Classic Apple Pie Page
FUNERAL PIE - $30.00
Traditional Amish pie.
PEAR FIG - $32.00
Pear Fig
BUTTERMILK PIE - $28.00
Tangy buttermilk adds zip to this pie with a cake-y layer and a smooth custard layer.
CARAMEL APPLE CIDER PIE - $30.00
A creamy custard pie spiked with apple cider syrup and Calvados. Topped with a layer of salted caramel. Caramel Apple Cider Pie Page
CHICAGO SUNRISE - $30.00
Tart Grapefruit and Chicago's very own Malort are combined to make this one of a kind pie. Chicago Sunrise Pie Page
CONFETTI CELEBRATION PIE - $28.00
A pie fit for any celebration! A cakey pie with rainbow sprinkles baked right in and a whipped cream wreath. Confetti Celebration Pie Page
FAT ELVIS PIE - $32.00
The name says it all. Chocolate, peanut butter & bananas in a graham cracker-peanut-pretzel crust. Fat Elvis Pie Page
GERMAN CHOCOLATE CHESS - $32.00
German Choc Chess
JEFFERSONVILLE PIE - $32.00
We spike our maple pecan pie with chocolate chips and bourbon and dress it with stripes of chocolate ganache. Jeffersonville Pie Page
MAPLE PECAN PIE - $32.00
Maple provides a more complex sweetness to our pecan pie.
OATMEAL PIE - $28.00
Oatmeal Pie is the perfect breakfast pie! Oatmeal with the sweetness of maple syrup and hint of spice.
PEANUT BUTTER PIE - $30.00
A sweet peanut butter filling in a ginger snap crust topped with chocolate ganache and chopped salted peanuts. Peanut Butter Pie Page
QUEEN VICTORIA - $32.00
Fluffernutter and banana Pie! Queen Victoria Pie Page
S'MORE PIE - $30.00
Serve up S'MORE PIE at your next campfire. Goes great with ghost stories & sing-alongs. No stick whittlin' required. S’Mores Pie Page
BOURBON-PECAN CHESS PIE - $28.00
A classic southern chess pie, flavored with bourbon and topped with candied pecans. Inspired by New Orleans.
CHOCOLATE CHESS PIE - $29.00
Our decadent chocolate take on the Southern staple. Customers nicknamed this the "Brownie Pie." Chocolate Chess Pie Page
CHOCOLATE PEANUT BUTTER CRUNCH - $32.00
Our Chocolate Chess with peanut butter swirled in and topped with a potato chip crunch March's Pie of the Month! Chocolate Peanut Butter Crunch Pie Page
LEMON CHESS PIE - $28.00
This is an old southern classic. A sweet lemon custard pie that is the perfect compliment to a coffee or espresso.
MEXICAN CHOCOLATE CHESS - $29.00
Our Chocolate Chess pie with cinnamon and chie
VINEGAR CHESS PIE - $26.00
This is the classic Chess Pie. A sweet vanilla cakey custard balanced with a little apple cider vinegar. Vinegar Chess Page
WHITE CHOCOLATE AND TOASTED COCONUT CHESS - $28.00
White Chocolate and Toasted Coconut Chess
BANANA CUSTARD - $28.00
A creamy custard with concentrated roasted banana flavor.
COCONUT CUSTARD - $28.00
A smooth custard with concentrated coconut flavor topped with toasted coconut.
EARL GREY CUSTARD - $30.00
Earl Grey tea steeped in custard. The perfect pie for tea time! Earl Grey Custard Pie Page
GINGER CUSTARD - $28.00
A pretty golden custard flavored and decorated with chopped candied ginger
HORCHATA - $28.00
Creamy vanilla and cinnamon rich custard. Horchata Pie Page
LEMON CUSTARD - $28.00
A fragrant and creamy lemon custard pie.
PUMPKIN PIE - $30.00
Real cream, vanilla, and quality spices make this a particularly good version of the classic fall pie. Pumpkin Pie Page
SOUR CREAM DUTCH APPLE - $30.00
Tart apples enveloped in a tangy sour cream custard topped with a sweet walnut crumble.
SOUR CREAM DUTCH BANANA - $30.00
banana slices baked in a tangy sour cream custard and topped with walnut crumble
SOUR CREAM DUTCH CRANBERRY - $30.00
Tart cranberries enveloped in a tangy sour cream custard topped with a sweet walnut crumble.
BANANA CREAM PIE - $30.00
Fresh bananas in a thick layer of vanilla pastry cream topped with white chocolate curls. Banana Cream Pie Page
CARAMEL BANANA CREAM - $32.00
Caramel pastry cream layered over top of caramel and fresh bananas. Garnished with dried banana chips around the edge. Caramel Banana Cream Page
CHOCOLATE CREAM PIE - $30.00
Rich thick chocolate pastry cream topped with lightly sweetened whipped cream and bittersweet chocolate curls. Chocolate Cream Pie Page
CHOCOLATE CREAM PIE WITH BANANAS! - $34.00
You guessed it. We put bananas in the bottom of our chocolate cream pie and it's really yummy. We also garnish the top with dried banana chips.
HOOSIER SUGAR CREAM PIE - $26.00
An Indiana farm classic. A sweet creamy brown sugar filling inside a buttery pie crust. Hoosier Sugar Cream Pie Page
RED LINE ESPRESSO CREAM - $32.00
Metropolis Coffee Co's Famous REDLINE ESPRESSO gives this delicate cream pie its deep coffee flavor. Red Line Espresso Cream Pie Page
ATLANTIC BEACH - $30.00
This pie is a staple in old school seafood shacks along the Eastern Seaboard. It combines a creamy, tangy lemon filling with a saltine cracker pie shell. Then it is topped with lightly sweetened whipped cream to make a wonderfully refreshing pie. Atlantic Beach Pie Page
KEY LIME PIE - $30.00
Fresh squeezed Key limes and a crisp ginger snap crust are the secrets to our version of this iconic pie. Topped with whipped cream.
KEYLIME PIE WITH MERINGUE TOPPING - $30.00
Fresh squeezed keylime and crisp gingersnap crust are the secret to our versions of this iconic pie.
PASSION FRUIT MERINGUE PIE - $30.00
Our exotic twist on an old favorite. Passion Fruit Meringue Pie Page
A NOTE ABOUT REHEATING SAVORY PIES AND QUICHES. - $0.00
Pre-ordered savory pies and quiches require reheating before serving. Pies are fully baked and then cooled and refrigerated for food safety. Pies purchased frozen are a pre-cooked filling in an unbaked crust. Instructions for reheating or baking are available by clicking the button to the left at the top of this menu.
CHICKEN POT PIE - $36.00
Chunks of chicken, potatoes, carrots, and peas sauted in a sherry cream sauce and baked in thyme flecked pie crust.
FROZEN CHICKEN POT PIE - $36.00
A frozen chicken pot pie you can bake at home at your convenience. Heating instructions included.
PORK-APPLE-SAGE SUPPER PIE - $36.00
Pork sausage, apples, onions, & potatoes sauted together and finished with a grainy mustard and creme fraiche, tucked into a Hoosier Mama pie crust.
ROASTED VEGGIE PIE - $32.00
Roasted squash, red pepper, rutabaga, celeriac and spinach are blended with feta cheese and tucked between 2 buttery crusts.
QUICHE LUANN - $28.00
Our creamy quiche with bacon onion and cheddar.
QUICHE, MUSHROOM GRUYERE - $28.00
Our creamy quiche with sauted mushrooms and gruyere.
QUICHE, MUSHROOM, SPAGHETTI SQUASH, KALE GRUYERE - $28.00
A veggie quiche with mushrooms, spaghetti squash, kale, and gruyere cheese.
QUICHE, SPINACH LEEK FETA - $28.00
Our creamy quiche base with spinach, leeks, and feta cheese
ONE DOZEN ASSORTED BREAKFAST PASTRIES - $33.00
An assortment of a dozen scones, muffins, turnovers, and sticky buns



Contact Us

By Phone:
(847) 868-8863

By email:
orders@hoosiermamapie.com


   
 
©2009 Hoosier Mama Pie Company ~ Designed by DesignScout ~ Contact